The central aims of the study were to: (1) conduct research designed to increase knowledge of the criminal prosecution of child sexual abuse, the characteristics of cases that go forward to prosecution and the factors associated with case attrition; (2) enhance current and foster new researcher-practitioner collaborations to understand the barriers to prosecution; and (3) develop sustained working partnerships designed to increase successful prosecution of perpetrators while minimizing trauma to victims and families and to develop future research.
The project conducted a retrospective analysis of how child sexual abuse cases referred for prosecution over a five year period (2009-2013) progressed through the system in several counties in one New England state. Using five coding forms developed through a pilot study, graduate student research assistants, along with the principal investigator, coded and entered into SPSS files information in assistant district attorney (ADA) case files, ADA trial record boxes, electronic databases of the district attorney (DA) office, and any child advocacy center files when available. ADA's were also available to the researchers to address any questions from the research team. These data files were used to prepare a flow chart of case attrition and conduct multivariate logistic regression analysis to determine the predictors of case outcomes.
Altogether, 500 child sexual abuse cases were selected for analysis. At each of four district attorney (DA) offices, 125 cases were randomly selected from a list of child sexual abuse cases provided by the office.
Cross-sectional
Child sexual abuse cases referred for prosecution during 2009-2013 in several counties in one New England state.
Child sexual abuse cases and the alleged victims and perpetrators in the cases.
Assistant district attorney (ADA) case files, ADA trial record boxes, district attorney (DA) electronic databases and any child advocacy center files when available.
The collection contains eight SPSS data files:
D1_General-Case-Details.sav (n=500; 103 variables): covers general case details, such as the alleged victim's age, date of intake (month and year) by the district attorney's office, who referred the case to the district attorney's office, whether a decision was made to prosecute the case and barriers to prosecuting the case.
D2_Background-Checks.sav (n=614; 9 variables): covers the background checks done on the alleged victims and perpetrators involved in each case: whether there were multiple victims affiliated with the case, whether the victims were victims or perpetrators in other cases and whether the perpetrators were victims or perpetrators in other cases.
D3_Trial-Information.sav (n=89; 123 variables): contains information about the cases that were prosecuted: the criminal charges and their dispositions, conditions imposed on the perpetrator (e.g., registration in sexual offence registry, mental health evaluation and Global Positioning System (GPS) monitoring), whether the case went before the court clerk or grand jury and various aspects of the trial process, such as trial type, motions to suppress evidence, use of outside experts, testimony given and victim impact statements.
D4_First-Victim-Details.sav (n=500; 289 variables) and D5_Add-Victim-Details.sav (n=54; 289 variables): contain information about the first and additional victims identified in the case, respectively, including victim characteristics (gender, age, race, ethnicity, immigration status, ability to speak English, living situation, family demographics, vulnerability, and health status), type and duration of alleged abuse, type of evidence collected by police/investigators, time elapsed between the first sex abuse incident involving the perpetrator and first disclosure by the victim, and the use of coercion, grooming or offering of exchange to accomplish sexual contact.
D6_First-Perp-Details.sav (n=500; 62 variables) and D7_Add-Perp-Details.sav (n=60; 62 variables): contain information about the first and additional perpetrators identified in the case, respectively, including the number of victims, type of abuse and characteristics of the perpetrator (gender, age, race, ethnicity, immigration issues, ability to speak English, vulnerability, health status, relationship to the victim and whether the perpetrator was already a registered sex offender when the case was opened).
D8_Medical-Information.sav (n=97; 35 variables): covers any medical information included in the cases with references to medical evidence: indications of physical/medical exams (e.g., physician exam, trip to emergency room, pregnancy, rape kit performed) and place of exam and exam findings.
Not applicable
None
Hide