[DDI-SRG] [DDI 3.0 0000007]: PhysicalRecordSegment in GrossRecordStructure shoudl be optional

[Wendy Thomas]

No...the the reference to the record segment has been moved to the 
BaseRecordLayout and all of the DataItems in the record layout are in the 
same segment. If you have to segments you have 2 base record layouts.

Have you looked at the updated spreadsheet in Item 6? This lists all the 
changes together.

You are also entering new bugs that are duplicates of old bugs 49--37

Also....rather than entering new bugs regarding old items please put you 
comments on the origianl bug. These solutions are not in the schemes yet 
so its unclear what you are refering to.

wendy


On Fri, 28 Sep 2007, Pascal Heus wrote:

> I would like to further discuss this resolution at the next meeting. I
> don't see the benefit of keeping this and it will add lots of
> unnecessary references: every DataItem/PhysicalLocation will require a
> reference to the segment (it's not a single reference from
> BaseRecordLayout). The vast majority of data files are single segment
> and this should be a default implied behavior. Segmentation information
> should only be required for segmented files.
> PhysicalRecordSegment should be optional as well as
> PhyicalRecordSegmentReference under DataItem/PhysicalLocation
>
>
> noreply at opendatafoundation.org wrote:
>> The following issue has been CLOSED
>> ======================================================================
>> http://mantis.ddialliance.org/view.php?id=7
>> ======================================================================
>> Reported By:                pheus
>> Assigned To:                wthomas
>> ======================================================================
>> Project:                    DDI 3.0
>> Issue ID:                   7
>> Category:                   !Schema
>> Reproducibility:            N/A
>> Severity:                   minor
>> Priority:                   normal
>> Status:                     closed
>> Related Module:             PhysicalData
>> XPath:                      /GrossRecordStructure/PhysicalRecordSegment
>> Related use case:           DExT
>> Implemented Solution:
>> Resolution:                 open
>> Fixed in Version:
>> ======================================================================
>> Date Submitted:             07-12-2007 14:52 PDT
>> Last Modified:              09-27-2007 16:40 PDT
>> ======================================================================
>> Summary:                    PhysicalRecordSegment in GrossRecordStructure shoudl
>> be optional
>> Description:
>> Most of the files are stored in a single segment and do not required this
>> information
>> ======================================================================
>>
>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>  wthomas - 07-21-07 10:11
>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>> see 2007/07/21 note on 0000013
>>
>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>  wthomas - 09-27-07 16:40
>> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>> NO CHANGE
>>
>> This retains a consistant definition and referencing structure. A single
>> identification and a single reference from the BaseRecordLayout is not
>> undue burden to retain a consistant structure.
>>
>> Issue History
>> Date Modified   Username       Field                    Change
>> ======================================================================
>> 07-12-07 14:52  pheus          New Issue
>> 07-12-07 14:52  pheus          Related Module            => PhysicalData
>> 07-12-07 14:52  pheus          XPath                     =>
>> /GrossRecordStructure/PhysicalRecordSegment
>> 07-12-07 14:52  pheus          Related use case          => DExT
>> 07-12-07 16:25  pheus          Status                   new => assigned
>> 07-12-07 16:25  pheus          Assigned To               => wthomas
>> 07-12-07 18:02  pheus          Assigned To              wthomas =>
>> 07-12-07 18:02  pheus          Status                   assigned => new
>> 07-21-07 10:10  wthomas        Status                   new => assigned
>> 07-21-07 10:10  wthomas        Assigned To               => wthomas
>> 07-21-07 10:11  wthomas        Note Added: 0000002
>> 09-27-07 16:40  wthomas        Note Added: 0000067
>> 09-27-07 16:40  wthomas        Status                   assigned => closed
>> ======================================================================
>>
>>
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> DDI-SRG mailing list
> DDI-SRG at icpsr.umich.edu
> http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/mailman/listinfo/ddi-srg
>

Wendy L. Thomas                          Phone: +1 612.624.4389
Data Access Core Director		 Fax:   +1 612.626.8375
Minnesota Population Center              Email: wlt at pop.umn.edu
University of Minnesota
50 Willey Hall
225 19th Avenue South
Minneapolis, MN 55455