The Source for Crime and Justice Data

View Record Details

Pub. Type Report
Title Justice Delayed? Time Consumption in Capital Appeals: A Multistate Study
Author(s) Latzer, Barry
Cauthen, James N.G.
Subtitle/Series Name Final Report
Pub. Date Mar 2007
Abstract For each State, every capital case resolved on direct appeal by the court of last resort (COLR) between January 1, 1992 and December 31, 2002 was examined. This generated a database of 1,676 cases. Measuring from date of death sentence, it took a median 966 days to complete direct appeals. Petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court added 188 days where certiorari was denied, and a median 250 days where certiorari was granted and the issues were decided on the merits. Virginia is the most efficient of all States in the study, with a median processing time from sentence to COLR ruling of 295 days. Measuring from notice of appeal to COLR decision, Georgia, at 297 days, is the fastest court of last resort. Ohio, Tennessee, and Kentucky were the least efficient COLRs, consuming respectively, 1,388, 1,350 and 1,309 days. However, Ohio subsequently reduced its time consumption by 25 percent by eliminating intermediate appeals court review. Median time consumption of capital appeals from notice of appeal to COLR decision was 921 days, far in excess of American Bar Association guidelines, which call for 50 percent of all appeals to be completed in 290 days. source
Issue/No. NCJ 217555
Producer John Jay College of Criminal Justice
Place of Production New York, NY

Related Studies

This publication is related to the following dataset(s):